A nonprofit hiring a development director should publish the opening on its careers page, advertise through a nonprofit job board, and share it with a fundraising network. Choose the geographic reach after deciding what the director will actually do. Someone meeting donors across one county needs a different recruiting plan from someone managing a national major gifts portfolio.
Score the fundraising experience you need
| Priority | Evidence to ask for | Who supplies support |
|---|---|---|
| Renew donors | Example of recovering a lapsed relationship | Director and donor records lead |
| Secure major gifts | Candidate’s own part in a completed gift | Executive director and trustees |
| Build systems | First stewardship calendar or reporting routine | Development operations |
For a school-based search, adapt the advancement director finalist briefing.
Sample posting opening: Director of Development
You will guide individual giving for [mission], inherit [portfolio or starting point], and partner with [leader] on donor visits. Your first priority is [specific fundraising outcome].
Complete before posting: pay range [minimum to maximum], work location [city and state], schedule [hours or travel], reports to [supervisor].
What will the new director inherit?
Hiring for a related position? Grant Writer or Institutional Giving Manager?.
Before buying an ad, ask the executive director, board chair, and finance lead to describe the first year of work. Who currently makes donor visits? Is there a usable donor database? Who writes appeals and acknowledges gifts? If the answers differ, settle them before promising candidates a functioning development department.
Two openings with the same title
A first fundraiser. Sample language: “You will build our individual giving program alongside the executive director. Your first priorities are to organize donor records, introduce a stewardship calendar, and prepare board members for donor conversations.” Add who handles gift entry and whether the role also owns grants or events.
An established portfolio. Sample language: “You will inherit an active major gifts portfolio, supervise our development associate, and partner with the executive director on donor visits. In your first season, you will review renewal opportunities and recommend a cultivation plan.” Include the approved salary range, reporting line, and actual travel expectations.
Where to advertise the opening
Use a nonprofit board to reach candidates who know mission-driven organizations. Add a fundraising association when donor strategy or portfolio management is central. For a place-based role, ask community partners to share the public link beyond the board’s personal contacts. For a regional portfolio, list the territory and where the director may live. A candidate should be able to decide whether the travel works before applying.
What if the first applications miss the mark?
Review a sample against the same two or three criteria. If event planners apply for a major gifts role, move portfolio ownership into the opening paragraph. If strong candidates withdraw after hearing about travel, update the location field and schedule. Fixing that mismatch gives the next advertising dollar a clearer purpose.
Employer resources · nonprofit hiring · Association of Fundraising Professionals career resources
Ask finalists to walk through a gift they helped secure
A board chair may hear a large gift amount and assume the candidate raised it single-handedly. Ask who identified the donor, who made the introduction, what the candidate personally did, and how the organization cared for the relationship afterward. Invite a de-identified example. For a first fundraiser, give equal weight to someone who built a dependable renewal process with modest resources.
Post a Development Director Opening
Questions employers ask
What if the board expects the director to bring donors?
Ask trustees which introductions they will make and who will participate in visits. Include that commitment in the posting so candidates can assess their partners in the work.
How should we evaluate a candidate from a larger shop?
Ask which tasks they personally completed and which went to research, operations, or communications colleagues. Compare that support with yours.
When should we advertise nationally?
Consider a wider search when the portfolio crosses regions or relocation is feasible. State the required home base and the travel pattern.
What first-year measure belongs in the interview?
Choose one tied to the starting position, such as renewing a defined group of donors or establishing a stewardship calendar. Explain what records the hire will inherit.
Should we require an existing donor list?
Ask how applicants built trust and managed a portfolio. Describe the relationships the organization will help them develop.
Should the board share the posting?
Yes. Give trustees one public link and a short description of the fundraising experience the search requires.
Related guide: How to Hire an Independent School Director of Advancement.
Hiring for Director of Development?
List your opening on Foundation List. Choose a 30-day posting for $119 or select a longer posting window.
Looking for a position? Search current openings.