How to Hire a Nonprofit Evaluation Manager Who Can Help Programs Improve

Foundation List News branded graphic featuring the official Foundation List logo in turquoise, charcoal, orange and lime green, with an orange NEWS banner.

How to Hire a Nonprofit Evaluation Manager Who Can Help Programs Improve

How to Hire a Nonprofit Evaluation Manager Who Can Help Programs Improve 1672 941 Foundation List Nonprofit Jobs - Nonprofit, Foundation, Healthcare & Education Job Board

Before recruiting an evaluation manager, ask a program director what decision better evidence would change. If the answer is whether to add an evening session, the hire needs access to participants and scheduling staff. If the need is to submit already-defined numbers to funders, a reporting specialist may be a better fit.

Start with a decision, then choose the measure

Consider a program where attendance declined. Enrollment totals alone cannot distinguish inconvenient hours, transportation problems, or a change in eligibility. Describe whether the evaluator can interview participants, examine administrative data, and work with staff to test improvements. Name who decides whether a recommendation becomes a program change.

Evaluation mandate worksheet

Decision the team faces Evidence to investigate Person who can act
Change session hours Attendance patterns and participant feedback Program director
Revise intake questions Completion and staff observations Intake supervisor
Renew a funded service Outcomes, limitations and costs Executive and funder liaison

Tell candidates how data reaches them

Publish the reporting line, data systems, quality of existing records, and time available from program staff. For community-facing work, name the service region, language needs, and travel. For a largely analytical position, specify remote work eligibility. Pair a mission-driven job board with evaluation practitioner networks.

Related guide: Grant Writer or Institutional Giving Manager?.

Sample posting opening for a Nonprofit Evaluation Manager

You will help [program teams] investigate [decision], develop workable measures, and explain findings to [audiences]. Your first assignment is [approved question].

Complete the posting with the approved pay range, schedule, work location, reporting line, and application instructions.

Post a Job From $119

A finalist exercise for the hiring committee

Give finalists an invented attendance decline and an incomplete survey. Ask what they can say now, what they would ask next, and how they would involve participants without overburdening them. Look for a distinction between an observed pattern and an explanation.

Professional resource: American Evaluation Association.

Test whether the organization is ready to use the hire’s work

Ask a program leader to complete this sentence before the search opens: “If the evidence shows ___, I can authorize ___ by ___.” If nobody can fill in the second blank, invite the decision-maker into the search intake. Give candidates a truthful description of how their findings will reach people with authority.

What to put in the finalist briefing

Share a fictional extract with missing responses and a short description of how information was collected. Score how the finalist describes the limits of the data as well as the recommendation they make.

Questions employers ask

Is a graduate degree essential?

Name the methods the hire must use and consider equivalent demonstrated experience.

Should grant writing sit in this job?

Describe any reporting or proposal support and how it fits the evaluation workload.

Which sample should we request?

Accept a redacted analysis with an explanation of the candidate’s own contribution.

Who owns data access?

Name the system owner and how the evaluator requests appropriate access.

What belongs in the salary discussion?

Publish the approved range and clarify supervision and travel responsibilities.

What is a useful early win?

Agree on one question a program lead will use in an upcoming decision.