How to Hire a Director of Advancement for an Independent School

Foundation List News branded graphic featuring the official Foundation List logo in turquoise, charcoal, orange and lime green, with an orange NEWS banner.

How to Hire a Director of Advancement for an Independent School

How to Hire a Director of Advancement for an Independent School 1672 941 Foundation List Nonprofit Jobs - Nonprofit, Foundation, Healthcare & Education Job Board

To hire an independent school director of advancement, have the head of school and board agree on the fundraising mandate before posting the opening. Name the work the director will inherit, advertise to school and advancement audiences, and interview against the same priorities you put in the ad.

Build a finalist scorecard with the head of school

Criterion Ask for Evidence to record
Donor strategy A portfolio decision the candidate owned Starting point, action and result
Head and trustee partnership A difficult preparation conversation Specific roles and follow-through
Staff capacity A campaign priority they deferred Tradeoff and rationale

Use the development director guide to distinguish personal fundraising results from team results.

Sample posting opening: Director of Advancement

You will lead [annual fund or campaign priority], partner with the head on [donor work], and supervise [team]. Our next school-year milestone is [approved milestone].

Complete before posting: pay range [minimum to maximum], work location [city and state], schedule [hours or travel], reports to [supervisor].

Post a Job From $119

Start with the next school year

What must be true by the end of the first school year? A school approaching a campaign may need someone who can organize prospect strategy and coach trustees through donor conversations. A school rebuilding its annual fund may need someone who can improve renewals, donor records, and parent communication. “Grow philanthropy” gives neither candidate enough information.

Describe the annual fund, alumni relations, major gifts, events, communications, and campaign work that actually sit in the position. Say who owns gift processing and acknowledgments during busy weeks. If the director is a department of one, explain what support the business office and head will provide.

Decide how the head and trustees participate

Candidates should know who makes introductions, attends donor visits, approves campaign messages, and evaluates performance. Explain the reporting line and how the director works with the development committee. State the evening event schedule and any travel to alumni communities. A candidate with experience outside education may bring strong relationship skills and still need to understand the school calendar.

Advertise across two professional communities

Publish the vacancy through education and mission-driven channels, then add an advancement network. Share it with independent school peers and regional fundraising contacts. For a campus-centered role, name the city and on-site expectations. If alumni travel is significant, specify the territory. Give every referral the same public job description and application route.

Use interview questions that reveal judgment

Ask, “A trustee offers an introduction to a family before we have agreed on a funding priority. What would you do next?” Listen for preparation, respect for the family relationship, and coordination with the head. Ask a second question about an annual appeal that missed expectations. Listen for how the candidate examined timing, audience, message, and stewardship.

Give finalists the same fictional scenario and evaluation criteria. Ask for a short discussion of priorities without requesting confidential donor names or a fundraising plan the school could put to work before hiring.

Employer resources · school hiring resources · CASE advancement recruiting resources

Give finalists a candid briefing from the head of school

Before the final interview, share a short description of the annual giving calendar, staff support, board participation, and any approved campaign plans. Ask what the candidate would need from the head in the first term. A promising answer connects donor visits, case development, and follow-up to named responsibilities. If the head cannot commit to regular donor conversations, resolve that constraint before asking a finalist to commit to a fundraising goal.

Post a School Advancement Opening

Questions employers ask

Who should chair the hiring decision?

Clarify who supervises and evaluates the director. Trustees can assess partnership skills while the designated hiring authority owns the decision.

Can higher education experience transfer?

Ask for an example of adapting a fundraising strategy to a smaller team and a community where parents, donors, and volunteers overlap.

How should we discuss evening events?

Give examples from the actual school calendar and explain how work schedules adjust during major events.

What should references help verify?

Ask a former supervisor how the candidate prepared leaders for donor meetings and followed through after visits. Use the same role-related questions across finalists.

Must the director have worked at an independent school?

Decide which relationships and routines require prior school experience and which can be learned. Explain that distinction in the qualifications.

What should candidates know about a planned campaign?

Share the approved stage, internal support, and the director’s role. Distinguish exploratory planning from an authorized campaign.

Related guide: Where to Advertise Non-Teaching School and College Jobs.

Hiring for Director of Advancement?

List your opening on Foundation List. Choose a 30-day posting for $119 or select a longer posting window.

Post a Job From $119

Looking for a position? Search current openings.