A community foundation hiring a donor services manager should define what happens after a donor opens a fund. Who welcomes the fundholder, answers questions about statements, routes grant recommendations, and follows up when a request needs clarification? Those handoffs make a more useful job description than “provide exceptional donor stewardship.”
Define who answers a fundholder’s question
| Question from donor | Who checks the facts | Who closes the loop |
|---|---|---|
| Has a grant been paid? | Grants and finance | Named donor contact |
| Why did the balance change? | Fund accounting | Donor services after review |
| Can we publicize the award? | Program and communications | Contact agreed with partner |
Agree on who contacts partners before an award is featured publicly.
Sample posting opening: Donor Services Manager
You will serve [fundholder group], coordinate answers with grants and finance, and own follow-up through resolution. You will also support [gatherings or advising scope].
Complete before posting: pay range [minimum to maximum], work location [city and state], schedule [hours or travel], reports to [supervisor].
Start with a donor’s first question
Hiring for a related position? How to Hire a Family Foundation Board Liaison.
Imagine a fundholder calls about a grant recommendation before a holiday. The donor wants to know whether the recipient has received payment. Map who can check the record, who can confirm the payment, and who calls the donor back. That last responsibility can belong to donor services even when finance or grants staff own the transaction. Put the division of work in the advertisement.
Decide which kind of donor role you need
Fundholder service. Look for attentive follow-through, accuracy with records, and the ability to explain processes in plain language. Describe the mix of phone, email, portal support, and in-person meetings.
Philanthropic advising. If the manager helps donors explore giving interests, convenes families, or introduces community partners, describe those conversations. Specify the counties served and whether the employee travels to meet donors there.
Fund development. If the employee must cultivate new funds, state that responsibility and how success will be evaluated. Someone excellent at retaining relationships deserves to know whether new business development is also part of the job.
Write a posting people from adjacent fields can recognize
For example: “As the primary contact for current fundholders, you will guide new donors through onboarding, coordinate answers with grants and finance, and follow up until questions are resolved. You will also host small gatherings where donors can learn from local nonprofit leaders.” Add the reporting line, portfolio size if available, salary range, and scope of decision-making.
Share the public listing with a foundation hiring network and regional philanthropy contacts. Consider applicants with relevant experience in nonprofit stewardship, alumni relations, or client service. State what the foundation will teach about its funds and policies.
Test the skill the donor will notice
Give applicants a fictional message about an unfamiliar entry on a fund statement. Ask for a short reply and a description of the internal checks they would make. A strong response acknowledges the question, avoids guessing, identifies the right colleague, and gives the donor a clear follow-up expectation. Use invented records so every applicant works from the same facts.
Employer resources · foundation hiring resources · Community Foundation National Standards for donor services and stewardship
Give the hiring panel a service-recovery exercise
A fundholder has received two different answers about the same payment. Ask the candidate to draft the first response, then explain how they would reconcile the records with grants and finance. Look for an acknowledgment of the discrepancy, a concrete follow-up date, and ownership of the next communication. Ask what they would document internally so another colleague can pick up the conversation if the manager is away.
Post a Foundation Donor Services Opening
Questions employers ask
Who should supervise donor services?
Choose the leader who can resolve competing service and development priorities. Name that reporting line and the regular contacts in finance and grants.
Should we disclose the number of funds served?
If approved, share it alongside contact frequency and team support. A raw fund count alone gives candidates little sense of workload.
How do we evaluate discretion?
Use an invented donor situation and ask what information the candidate would verify before sharing, and with whom.
Which early improvement should we ask for?
Ask the hire to map common donor questions to internal owners and flag where requests routinely lose an owner or follow-up date.
Is donor services the same as a major gifts role?
They can overlap. Specify whether the position supports current fundholders, solicits new gifts, or carries both responsibilities.
Should local connections be required?
Describe the community knowledge and travel the role needs. Ask how candidates would build relationships across the service area.
Related guide: Program Officer vs. Grants Manager: Which Title Fits?.
Hiring for Donor Services Manager?
List your opening on Foundation List. Choose a 30-day posting for $119 or select a longer posting window.
Looking for a position? Search current openings.