How to Hire an Interim Executive Director While Your Nonprofit Board Runs a Search

Foundation List News branded graphic featuring the official Foundation List logo in turquoise, charcoal, orange and lime green, with an orange NEWS banner.

How to Hire an Interim Executive Director While Your Nonprofit Board Runs a Search

How to Hire an Interim Executive Director While Your Nonprofit Board Runs a Search 1672 941 Foundation List Nonprofit Jobs - Nonprofit, Foundation, Healthcare & Education Job Board

When a nonprofit board needs interim leadership, write the transition assignment before advertising the title. Is the interim there to maintain services, repair a strained partnership, or prepare the organization for its next executive director? The answer determines whom to recruit, what authority to grant, and what the board should expect at handoff.

One-page board mandate for an interim director

Board decision Complete before advertising Who confirms
Assignment and term [Transition priority] through [anticipated handoff] Board chair
Decision authority May approve [actions]; board retains [decisions] Board and interim supervisor
Handoff Deliver [open commitments, deadlines and staff priorities] by [date] Chair and transition lead

Clarify who can make budget decisions while the permanent search runs.

Sample posting opening: Interim Executive Director

During [anticipated term], you will lead [organization] through [transition], protect [service or relationship], and prepare a handoff for the incoming executive director. You report to [board contact].

Complete before posting: pay range [minimum to maximum], work location [city and state], schedule [hours or travel], reports to [supervisor].

Post a Job From $119

Put the chair and the staff lead at the same table

Ask each to identify the first three decisions that cannot wait for a permanent hire. Compare their lists. A funding renewal, a vacant program leadership role, and a facilities commitment may each need a different decision-maker. Record what the interim can approve, what requires a board vote, and how quickly the chair can convene the board.

Explore Foundation List’s nonprofit hiring resources.

Advertise the term as honestly as the mandate

Sample opening: “Our board seeks an interim executive director to guide staff through a leadership transition, maintain key funding relationships, and prepare a handoff for the incoming leader. The chair will meet weekly with the interim. A separate committee owns the permanent search.” Add the anticipated duration, time commitment, compensation, on-site schedule, and policy on eligibility for the permanent position.

A local search makes sense when the interim must be present quickly and routinely. A wider search may work when the board can cover travel or accept partial remote work. Spell out the arrangement before asking experienced leaders to make time for interviews.

Ask finalists to prioritize a difficult first week

Use a fictional Friday morning. A funder wants reassurance, staff have heard conflicting messages, and a trustee wants to announce a reorganization. Ask what the finalist would do before the weekend, what could wait, and what they would ask the chair to handle. Listen for sequencing, respect for decision authority, and a way to keep staff informed.

Post an Interim Executive Director Opening

Professional resource: BoardSource emergency leadership transition plan.

Employer questions

Who owns the permanent search?

Name the board committee or designated leader in the posting.

Can the interim apply for the permanent job?

Set and disclose the board’s policy before outreach begins.

Should we state an end date?

Give the anticipated term and explain how extensions would be agreed.

What if we need part-time leadership?

Specify working days, availability between them, and who handles urgent decisions.

What belongs in the handoff?

Ask for open decisions, commitments, key relationships, and upcoming deadlines.

Who should check references?

Designate a board representative to ask prior transition partners about communication, judgment, and handoff quality.

Related hiring guide: Defining finance leadership responsibilities.

Hiring for Interim Executive Director?

List your opening on Foundation List. Choose a 30-day posting for $119 or select a longer posting window.

Post a Job From $119

Looking for a position? Search current openings.