Hiring a Philanthropic Advisor for a Community Foundation: Define the Donor Portfolio First

Foundation List News branded graphic featuring the official Foundation List logo in turquoise, charcoal, orange and lime green, with an orange NEWS banner.

Hiring a Philanthropic Advisor for a Community Foundation: Define the Donor Portfolio First

Hiring a Philanthropic Advisor for a Community Foundation: Define the Donor Portfolio First 1672 941 Foundation List Nonprofit Jobs - Nonprofit, Foundation, Healthcare & Education Job Board

A community foundation should decide what happens after a donor asks, “Where could this fund make a difference?” A philanthropic advisor might facilitate a family conversation, connect donors with community knowledge, or cultivate prospective funds. Those assignments require different experience. Name the portfolio and its purpose before setting the title.

Separate advising from fund development

List the conversations that fill a typical month. Are they primarily with existing fundholders, prospective donors, professional advisers, or nonprofit partners? State who owns new-fund cultivation, who answers transaction questions, and when tax or legal questions go to the donor’s own advisers. Explain how the role partners with grants staff when donors ask about community needs.

Donor portfolio briefing

Conversation Responsibility to define Partner to involve
Family wants to clarify interests Facilitate discussion Donor services
Donor asks about community needs Connect interests with local knowledge Program team
Prospective fundholder requests details Define cultivation and follow-up Development lead

Advertise the territory the advisor will serve

For a place-based portfolio, identify the counties, travel pattern, and evening gatherings. For dispersed donor families, describe remote meetings and who budgets for travel. Use philanthropy and nonprofit hiring channels and invite candidates to explain how they build relationships across communities, including communities new to them.

Related guide: How to Hire a Scholarship Program Manager.

Sample posting opening for a Community Foundation Philanthropic Advisor

You will advise [fundholder group] across [region], facilitate giving conversations, and work with [program and donor services teams]. The role includes [new-fund expectations].

Complete the posting with the approved pay range, schedule, work location, reporting line, and application instructions.

Post a Job From $119

A finalist exercise for the hiring committee

A family’s members disagree about a giving priority and ask the advisor to choose. Ask the finalist how they would prepare, facilitate the conversation, and agree on a next step. Listen for questions that clarify donor intent and respect what the foundation can promise.

Professional resource: Council on Foundations.

Give candidates a de-identified portfolio preview

Describe three representative situations: a long-standing donor seeking a new issue area, a prospective fundholder referred by a professional adviser, and a family preparing its first joint giving conversation. Ask which situation needs the most preparation and why. Their questions reveal whether they see this as advising, cultivation, or transaction support.

Choose the first portfolio review

Agree on which relationships need introductions, what the foundation has permission to share, and who owns follow-up after a meeting. These details give the incoming advisor a useful starting point.

Questions employers ask

Must the hire bring a book of donors?

Assess the ability to build relationships and explain the portfolio being inherited.

Is this a planned giving position?

State whether gift planning forms part of the job and who provides specialist support.

Who supervises the advisor?

Identify the leader who balances donor service and growth priorities.

How should we assess community knowledge?

Ask how the candidate would learn from partners beyond existing contacts.

Should we include fundraising targets?

Only share approved targets with context about inherited and prospective relationships.

What should references address?

Ask how the candidate followed through on commitments involving several parties.