Hiring a Scholarship Program Manager for a Community Foundation: Plan Around Award Season

Foundation List News branded graphic featuring the official Foundation List logo in turquoise, charcoal, orange and lime green, with an orange NEWS banner.

Hiring a Scholarship Program Manager for a Community Foundation: Plan Around Award Season

Hiring a Scholarship Program Manager for a Community Foundation: Plan Around Award Season 1672 941 Foundation List Nonprofit Jobs - Nonprofit, Foundation, Healthcare & Education Job Board

A foundation hiring a scholarship program manager should describe its busiest month. Opening applications, answering family questions, organizing reviewers, issuing notices, and confirming payments can overlap. Candidates need to see the sequence and the support available. The title alone does not tell them whether they are running a program or processing a queue.

Award-season coverage planner

Stage Owner to identify Backup to arrange
Application opening Applicant communications lead Help desk during peak inquiries
Selection Authorized review lead Alternate panel coordination
Award and renewal Program and payment contacts Coverage during school deadlines

Separate program ownership from seasonal capacity

List the number of cycles, participating schools, and renewable awards if those figures are approved for publication. Ask the team to identify where applicants waited last year. If the delay came from unclear instructions, look for someone who can redesign communication. If it came from a flood of complete applications needing review, specify temporary support or volunteer coordination.

Related hiring guide: Program Officer vs. Grants Manager: Which Title Fits?.

Define decision boundaries

Explain who sets eligibility rules, who screens for completeness, who selects recipients, and who releases payment. Say where questions and exceptions go. The program manager should be able to explain the process to a student without making an award decision that belongs elsewhere. For local outreach roles, name the service region and school visits. For online administration, specify working hours and any on-site ceremonies.

Sample job posting: Scholarship Program Manager

You will manage [award cycles], coordinate reviewers, guide applicants through published requirements, and work with finance on approved payments. Peak activity falls in [months].

Include the approved pay range, reporting line, work location, schedule, and application instructions.

Post a Job From $119

Interview with an applicant-facing problem

A reviewer has not returned scores, the announcement date is approaching, and a student wants to know whether to accept another offer. Ask the candidate to draft a response to the student and a separate escalation to the selection lead. Score clarity, fairness, and realistic follow-up. Avoid requesting real applicant files or confidential donor criteria.

Professional resource: Council on Foundations scholarship administration resource.

Plan for the day after award notices go out

In the staffing brief, assign one person to returned emails, another to questions about the published process, and a named contact for payment coordination. Decide who can authorize a correction if an award notice has an error. This often reveals a need for temporary administrative coverage alongside the year-round program manager.

A useful reference question

Ask how the candidate handled an applicant communication that needed correction. Look for ownership, timely escalation, and a consistent message to affected applicants.

Related hiring decision: Grants Systems Manager or Grants Manager? Hire the Right Person for a Foundation Platform Change.

Questions employers ask

Should we require financial aid experience?

Decide whether the job needs aid-office knowledge or primarily program administration.

Who handles donor questions?

Assign a contact and explain when donor services takes the lead.

Where can we reach candidates?

Use a foundation job board and regional education or scholarship networks.

What workload details matter?

Give the award calendar, program scope, expected travel, and seasonal support.

What should applicants submit?

Ask for an example of managing a deadline-driven process with multiple reviewers.

What first improvement is useful?

A calendar that gives each award step an owner, backup, and communication deadline.