Hiring a Community Foundation Controller: What to Ask About Funds, Fees, and Month-End Close

Foundation List News branded graphic featuring the official Foundation List logo in turquoise, charcoal, orange and lime green, with an orange NEWS banner.

Hiring a Community Foundation Controller: What to Ask About Funds, Fees, and Month-End Close

Hiring a Community Foundation Controller: What to Ask About Funds, Fees, and Month-End Close 1672 941 Foundation List Nonprofit Jobs - Nonprofit, Foundation, Healthcare & Education Job Board

A community foundation hiring a controller should describe how money and information move between its general ledger, fund records, investment statements, and donor reports. “Oversee accounting” leaves candidates guessing whether they will review a close prepared by staff or personally reconcile discrepancies across systems.

Assign the monthly close handoffs

Close item Who prepares it? Who verifies it?
Fund balances [Fund accounting owner] [Controller or reviewer]
Award payments [Grants or finance team] [Approval owner]
Fundholder statements [Statement preparer] [Finance and donor services leads]

Map the grants manager’s responsibilities before assigning payment follow-up.

Sample posting opening: Community Foundation Controller

You will own monthly fund reconciliations, supervise [team], and coordinate the close with grants and donor services. The CFO retains [planning or investment oversight].

Complete before posting: pay range [minimum to maximum], work location [city and state], schedule [hours or travel], reports to [supervisor].

Post a Job From $119

Reconstruct the last close before writing the ad

Ask finance, donor services, and grants staff where they waited for one another last month. Did finance receive a gift designation late? Did a fee allocation require a manual review? Did someone need to explain a difference between a fund statement and the ledger? Pick two representative tasks and include them in the posting, along with who signs off.

Explore Foundation List’s foundation hiring resources.

Explain the relationship with the chief financial officer

A clear summary might read: “The controller owns the monthly close and fund-level reconciliations, supervises the accounting team, and coordinates audit schedules. The CFO owns long-range planning and presents financial strategy to the board.” Adapt this split to your foundation. Include systems, team size, outsourced services, and which reports the controller prepares for colleagues outside finance.

Pair a foundation job board with accounting networks. If the role can be done away from headquarters, disclose any travel for audit preparation, committee meetings, or team supervision. If a candidate must be local, explain the actual work that takes place on site.

Give finalists a reconciliation, not a trivia test

Provide invented figures: a fund statement shows a balance of $105,000 and the corresponding ledger balance is $103,500. Ask the candidate to describe the records they would request and the order they would check timing, coding, fees, and adjustments. The difference is $1,500; the exercise tests whether the candidate resists assigning a cause before tracing the entries. Ask how they would explain the open item to donor services while the review is underway.

Post a Foundation Controller Opening

Professional resource: Community Foundation National Standards.

Employer questions

Must candidates come from another foundation?

Ask which fund accounting and reconciliation experience transfers, then identify foundation-specific training.

Should the controller meet donors?

Describe whether the role answers fundholder questions directly or supports donor services.

What should we disclose about a backlog?

Name the work to be stabilized and the resources available to do it.

Who should assess technical skills?

Use a finance reviewer familiar with the foundation’s records and controls.

Should we include investments in the title?

Only if investment accounting or oversight materially shapes the mandate. Define the boundary.

What makes a useful first deliverable?

An agreed close calendar with owners, review steps, and dependencies.

Related hiring guide: Hiring the controller’s donor services partner.

Hiring for Community Foundation Controller?

List your opening on Foundation List. Choose a 30-day posting for $119 or select a longer posting window.

Post a Job From $119

Looking for a position? Search current openings.