How to Advertise a Foundation’s First Paid Staff Position

A foundation should advertise its first paid staff position after trustees agree on the work they intend to transfer and the authority that goes with it. A trustee-led foundation may need an executive director to guide strategy, a foundation administrator to coordinate operations, or a grants manager to run a reliable awards process. The most senior title is not automatically the most useful hire. Start with the decisions waiting for an owner.

Post a Foundation Job

Reconstruct the last grant cycle together

Have trustees independently describe what happened between opening applications and issuing payments. Who answered applicant questions, maintained the records, coordinated review, prepared the board packet, documented decisions, and followed up with partners? Include work performed by an accountant, attorney, consultant, or family office when relevant. The board may discover that a task attributed to “the foundation” actually depends on a volunteer checking messages during personal time.

Then distinguish work trustees want to delegate from decisions they intend to retain. Preparing recommendations is different from approving awards. Coordinating trustee meetings is different from setting strategy. Responding to an inquiry about timing is different from committing the foundation to a new funding priority. Candidates can evaluate the job only when these boundaries are visible. Trustees can evaluate performance more fairly when the assignment is written down.

Three legitimate first hires

An executive director can be appropriate when the foundation needs a leader to develop strategy with trustees, manage outside relationships, set operating priorities, and represent the institution. Describe where the director can act independently and where trustees must decide. If the foundation has never had employees, say what administrative work remains hands-on. A one-person office may be a compelling assignment for the right candidate when expectations are clear.

A foundation administrator can fit when trustees will keep strategy and grant decisions while an employee takes ownership of day-to-day operations. The work may include calendars, correspondence, meeting preparation, vendor coordination, and records. Specify the mix. An administrator expected to mediate competing requests from several trustees needs one supervisor with authority to resolve priorities. Do not leave that arrangement to the employee to negotiate after arrival.

A grants manager can fit when the persistent challenge is moving awards through a dependable process. Describe intake, eligibility screening, records, agreements, payments, and reporting. Explain who handles program judgment and who controls payment authorization. In a foundation, grants management commonly concerns outgoing awards; candidates from operating nonprofits may associate the title with securing incoming grants. Make the direction of funding clear in the opening paragraph.

Test the title with a Friday afternoon decision

Imagine that a grantee asks to change a reporting date, a trustee wants material for an unexpected meeting, and a payment question reaches the public inbox. Ask what the new employee should do first, what they may decide, and whose answer they must obtain. If trustees expect someone to redesign the grant process and negotiate institutional priorities, an administrative title could understate the responsibility.

Now reverse the question. If every substantive decision remains with individual trustees, would a prospective executive director have the authority necessary to succeed? A senior title with no delegated decisions may attract leaders expecting a different role. It is reasonable to hire an experienced administrator or program operator first and revisit leadership structure as the foundation’s work evolves. Describe the present mandate rather than offering a speculative promotion.

Prepare a one-page trustee authorization brief

Purpose and first assignment. Complete this sentence: “We are hiring our first employee so that [people served] can rely on [specific improvement].” Add the first grant cycle, meeting, or operating milestone the person will own. If trustees give several conflicting answers, identify the highest priority and state which work can wait. An advertisement cannot settle a disagreement about the organization’s purpose.

Supervision and decisions. Name the supervisor, the person who handles questions when that supervisor is away, and the frequency of performance conversations. List examples of decisions the employee can make, can recommend, and must refer. Specify which professional advisers remain available. A first employee should not be expected to serve simultaneously as legal counsel, investment adviser, bookkeeper, and grantmaker simply because no other staff currently exist.

Employment terms. Confirm the approved compensation range, time commitment, work location, anticipated travel, and budget for ordinary operating support. If the job is part-time, describe availability expectations between scheduled days. If trustees hold evening meetings, tell candidates how often and where. Verify which benefits and equipment arrangements are authorized before including them in the posting.

Search ownership. Identify the person who releases the public advertisement, the application destination, the review committee, and the final hiring authority. Decide whether trustees may nominate candidates, how nominees enter the regular process, and when references will be requested. A well-connected board can generate introductions while giving candidates from outside its immediate network an equally clear route to consideration.

Write a first-hire posting applicants can trust

Begin by telling readers this is the first paid staff appointment. Experienced candidates will want to know which systems are in place and what they will build. Mention established advisers and records that will transfer to the person. If the grant calendar exists largely in a trustee’s inbox, say the first assignment involves consolidating it. Describing a real opportunity to create order is more credible than implying a mature operation exists.

Sample introduction: “Our trustees seek a [role] to coordinate [grantmaking or operating responsibility] for [foundation purpose]. This is our first paid staff appointment. You will report to [supervisor], work with [advisers or committees], and have authority to [decisions]. During your first grant cycle, you will [approved assignment]. Trustees retain responsibility for [reserved decisions].” Complete the description with pay, location, hours, application instructions, and review timing.

For a family foundation, describe communication and reporting relationships in professional terms. A candidate needs to know who gives direction when family members hold different committee roles. The public advertisement need not disclose private family information. It should explain how conflicting requests are resolved and who approves communications on behalf of the foundation. That distinction helps candidates judge their ability to do the job respectfully and effectively.

Choose a hiring geography from the actual work

A place-based foundation may value knowledge of a region’s communities, but “must be local” can mean several things. Does the person need to attend frequent site visits, maintain an office near trustees, or travel across a multicounty service area? State those obligations. A candidate outside the board’s personal networks may have strong regional experience or a convincing plan for learning from local partners.

A broader search can be appropriate when the work involves national grantmaking or a specialized function. Identify where the person may live, when in-person meetings are required, and how travel is supported. Pair a foundation or mission-driven job board with a philanthropic professional network. Share the same public link with community organizations so interested people can read the approved terms rather than relying on an informal description from a trustee.

Evaluate the work the employee will actually inherit

For an administrator, offer a fictional board calendar with overlapping deadlines. Ask for a plan to coordinate inputs, obtain approvals, and send updates. For a grants manager, provide an invented renewal with a missing document, a time-sensitive payment, and separate program and finance questions. Ask how the candidate would establish the record and assign follow-up without making an unauthorized decision.

For an executive director, present two possible priorities for the first year and limited staff capacity. Ask what the finalist would learn from trustees and community partners before recommending a sequence. Look for judgment about tradeoffs and a realistic plan for working with a board. Give each finalist the same information and reasonable preparation time. Do not request a usable strategic plan based on confidential grant information as unpaid interview work.

References can illuminate first-employee conditions that a conventional interview misses. Ask a former supervisor how the candidate created structure when several stakeholders wanted different things. Ask how they communicated an unresolved issue without escalating every ordinary decision. Clarify the resources available in the former role so the board can compare environments fairly. A candidate from a large institution may be quite hands-on, but the title alone will not establish that.

Agree on a handoff before the employee starts

Build a list of systems, records, relationships, and open decisions. Assign a trustee or adviser to introduce each one. Specify which access must be set up and reviewed, who can grant it, and who provides training. Arrange a first meeting with the supervisor and identify the board meeting at which early progress will be reviewed. A first employee deserves the same onboarding discipline as someone joining an established department.

A sensible early deliverable might be a verified grant calendar, a decision log, and an agreed process for responding to inquiries. Avoid measuring the new employee against promises the trustees have not yet authorized or priorities that change at every meeting. Set a planned opportunity to revisit the role after the foundation has observed a real grant cycle with staff support.

Ask a trustee outside the search group to read the final draft

Give that trustee the advertisement without the background notes. Ask what the employee can approve, who sets priorities, and how the employee will know the first year has gone well. Compare the answers with the authorization brief. If the reader assumes the new hire will approve awards when trustees intend to retain that decision, change the public language. This is less expensive than discovering the mismatch during a finalist interview, and it helps the board communicate consistently when prospective applicants call trustees directly.

Questions trustees ask before publishing

Can the first employee work part-time?

Yes, if the duties, peak workload, availability expectations, and supervision fit the arrangement. Identify who covers urgent issues on days the employee is unavailable.

Does the foundation need an executive director first?

Choose that title when trustees intend to delegate leadership and strategic responsibility. An administrator or grants manager may be more appropriate when operational work is the immediate need.

Who should review applications?

Name a small group with clear criteria and a designated decision-maker. Ask trustees to distinguish skills essential on arrival from foundation-specific knowledge the board can teach.

Should we advertise if a trustee knows a candidate?

Decide on the selection process before assessing individuals. A public opportunity lets the board compare relevant experience and invites interest beyond existing relationships.

How do we explain compensation?

Publish the approved range and describe the work schedule, support, and scope it covers. Verify any additional terms with the person authorized to make the offer.

When is the job ready for Foundation List?

Release it after the board agrees on title, authority, pay, location, supervisor, application route, and final approval. Use the same public description throughout the search so the opportunity candidates evaluate is the appointment trustees intend to make.

Related employer guides: Posting a client opening · Hiring after a grant award.

Employer resources: Sector hiring and posting options · Choosing a grantmaking title · National Center for Family Philanthropy.